Boiler
Oil-to-Gas Conversion in Brooklyn & Across NYC
Converting a house from oil heat to gas is not one job — it is five, and the order matters. Gas has to be available at the curb, the new boiler has to be sized to the building rather than to the old unit, the interior gas piping has to carry the load, the venting usually has to change, and the oil tank has to be dealt with properly. We plan the whole sequence before anything is ordered.

The first question is not which boiler you want — it is whether gas is available at your address at all, and on what terms. A gas main running down your street does not automatically mean a service line runs to your house, and the utility (National Grid or Con Edison, depending where you are) controls that part of the job, its cost, and its timeline. Some blocks are straightforward. Others require a street opening, and the utility's queue is the utility's queue. We tell people to confirm availability and get the utility's answer in writing before spending money on anything else, because every other decision in a conversion depends on it.
The second thing that goes wrong is sizing. A great many oil boilers in New York were oversized when they were installed, and the easiest mistake in a conversion is to read the old unit's rating and order the gas equivalent. That carries the original error forward for another twenty years. An oversized boiler short-cycles — it fires, satisfies the thermostat quickly, shuts down, and repeats — which wastes fuel, wears components faster, and heats unevenly. A conversion is the one moment when correcting that costs nothing extra, because you are specifying new equipment anyway. We do a heat-load calculation against the actual building: square footage, insulation, window and radiator count, and how the existing distribution is laid out.
Venting is where conversion budgets get surprised. An old oil boiler typically vents into a masonry chimney that was built for it. A modern high-efficiency condensing gas boiler produces cooler, wetter exhaust that an unlined masonry chimney is not suited to, so the chimney either needs a properly sized liner or the unit gets direct-vented through a sidewall instead. Which one applies depends on the equipment chosen and the building — and on a row house or attached property, sidewall venting has to account for where the exhaust terminates relative to windows and the neighbour's property. This gets decided during planning, not on installation day.
Finally, the oil tank. Whether it is in the basement or buried in the yard, it cannot simply be left full and forgotten once the oil boiler is gone. Decommissioning means the tank is properly emptied and cleaned, then either removed or abandoned in place to the applicable requirements, with the paperwork that goes with it. Buried tanks carry the additional risk that a leak may already have happened, which is a different and larger problem than the conversion itself. We raise this at the planning stage rather than at the end, because it affects both the budget and the schedule, and because discovering it late is how conversions stall half-finished.
Warning Signs
Signs You Need Oil-to-Gas Conversion
Oil deliveries and oil heat have become the largest line in your running costs
The existing oil boiler is at or past its service life and repairs are recurring
Gas is already serving the block and neighbouring houses have converted
You are replacing the boiler anyway, which is the cheapest moment to change fuel
An aging buried or basement oil tank you would rather not replace
Soot, odour, or oil staining around the burner and the surrounding floor
A gut renovation or major mechanical replacement is already planned
Uneven heat the existing system has never resolved, suggesting it was sized wrong
Common Causes
What Usually Causes This
Realistic explanations, not a diagnosis of your specific property — an on-site visit confirms the actual cause.
- Operating cost — the fuel-price gap between oil and gas is the most common reason homeowners start the conversation
- An oil boiler reaching end of life, making the fuel decision unavoidable rather than optional
- An oil tank that is aging, leaking, or simply unwanted, especially a buried one
- Gas service newly extended down a street, making conversion possible where it previously was not
- Maintenance burden — oil systems need burner service, filters, and tank monitoring that gas systems do not
- A renovation already opening up the mechanical space, so the incremental cost of converting is lower than doing it alone
- Resale considerations, where buyers in some neighbourhoods treat an old buried oil tank as a liability
Our Process
How It Works
Confirm gas availability first
Before anything else, we help you establish whether the utility can serve your address, what they will charge, and how long their side will take — in writing. Every other step depends on this answer.
Heat-load calculation
We size the new boiler to the building, not to the old unit's rating. A conversion is the one chance to correct an oversizing mistake without paying extra for the privilege.
Survey the gas piping and electrical
Interior gas piping has to carry the new load, and existing runs sized for a cooktop will not. We check what can be reused and what has to be upsized before equipment is selected.
Decide the venting approach
Chimney liner or sidewall direct vent, decided against the equipment and the building — including where exhaust terminates on an attached or row property.
Plan the oil tank decommissioning
Removal or abandonment in place, scheduled as part of the project rather than left as an afterthought, with the condition of a buried tank assessed before the work is priced.
Permits and licensed work
Gas line work and permit-required portions are coordinated through our licensed partner network, with filings and inspections handled as the scope requires — see our Licensing & Compliance page.
Installation, commissioning, and handover
The new system is installed, combustion-tested, and run through a full heat cycle under real conditions. We then walk you through the controls and what the system actually needs from you.
Repair vs. Replacement
Which One Actually Makes Sense
Repair Often Makes Sense When
- The existing oil boiler is mid-life, sound, and heating the building evenly
- Gas is not available at the address, or the utility's cost to bring it in is disproportionate
- The oil tank is in good condition and recently assessed
- You expect to sell or substantially renovate within a short horizon, so the payback period will not land with you
Replacement Often Makes Sense When
- The oil boiler is at end of life, so you are buying new equipment regardless and the fuel decision is free to make
- The oil tank needs replacement or removal anyway, which removes a large part of the conversion's incremental cost
- Gas already serves the block and the utility's connection cost is modest
- The existing system was sized wrong from the start — a fault no repair corrects
Conversion is an investment with a payback period, not an emergency repair, and the honest answer sometimes is to keep running the oil system for now. The economics turn on three things: what the utility charges to bring gas in, what condition the oil tank is in, and how much life the existing boiler has left. We would rather work those numbers through with you than assume the answer is always to convert.
Pricing Guidance
Typical Cost Factors
Conversion costs vary more than almost any other job we quote, because a large share of the total sits with the utility rather than with us. Pricing follows a site survey and the utility's own answer. What moves the number:
Final pricing follows a site survey and confirmation of the utility's own costs and timeline, which are quoted separately by them and not by us.
NYC Considerations
What's Different About NYC Housing
- Gas availability is decided block by block, not neighbourhood by neighbourhood — a converted house two doors down is encouraging but not proof your address can be served on the same terms
- Attached rowhouses and semi-detached homes limit where a sidewall vent can terminate, since exhaust placement has to account for windows and the adjoining property
- Masonry chimneys in older NYC housing stock were built for oil and frequently need lining before they can safely vent a modern gas boiler
- Buried oil tanks are common in the outer boroughs and on Long Island, and their condition should be established before a conversion is priced rather than after
- Co-op and condo buildings will generally require board approval before any work touching gas service, venting, or a shared chimney
- Utility timelines are seasonal — starting a conversion in October means competing with everyone else who waited for the first cold night
Our Work
Before & After
Photo gallery of specific completed jobs coming soon — here's what the visit typically looks like.
Oil-to-Gas Conversion photos coming soon
Oil-to-Gas Conversion photos coming soon
Reviews
What Homeowners Say
“I had a leak in my living room ceiling and couldn't figure out where it was coming from. Keon and his employee showed up quickly after I reached out. They were professional, patient, and took the time to explain everything to me.”
Lisa B.
Brooklyn, NY · Pipe Repair
“Worked on the complicated pipes in our 125-year-old home. We were satisfied with the work and would hire again.”
Makeba D.
Brooklyn, NY · Pipe Repair
“Keon was able to come the same day. He was very meticulous pinpointing the issue and tried to be as minimally invasive as possible.”
Elias Z.
Brooklyn, NY · Pipe Repair
Service Area
Oil-to-Gas Conversion Across New York
Choose your borough for local details and neighborhood coverage.
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
There is no useful flat figure, because a large share of the cost belongs to the utility rather than to us — bringing a gas service line to the house can dwarf the boiler itself on some blocks and be modest on others. The honest sequence is to get the utility's number first, then price the mechanical work against it. We will not quote a conversion before that answer exists.
You contact the gas utility for your address — National Grid or Con Edison depending where you are — and request a service availability determination. A gas main on your street does not guarantee you can be connected affordably, so get their answer, including cost and timeline, in writing before committing to anything else.
Sometimes, but do not assume it. A modern high-efficiency gas boiler produces cooler, wetter exhaust than an old oil burner did, and an unlined masonry chimney is generally not suited to it. The usual outcomes are a correctly sized liner or direct venting through a sidewall. Which one applies is decided during planning, against your equipment and your building.
It has to be properly decommissioned — emptied, cleaned, and then either removed or abandoned in place to the applicable requirements, with the accompanying documentation. A buried tank carries the extra question of whether it has already leaked, which is a larger problem than the conversion and one worth establishing before the job is priced rather than during it.
Often not yet. Conversion has a payback period, and if the existing boiler is mid-life, correctly sized, and heating evenly, the economics usually argue for waiting. The moment conversion makes most sense is when you are replacing the boiler anyway — then the fuel decision costs you nothing extra to make.
Our portion is typically a small number of days once equipment is on site. The schedule is usually set by the utility's side — service line installation and meter setting — which can run weeks and is not something we control. Plan the project around their timeline, not ours, and start well ahead of heating season.
Usually, though how much depends on fuel prices and on what you are replacing. A meaningful part of the saving often comes from correct sizing rather than from the fuel switch itself — an oversized boiler short-cycles and wastes fuel whatever it burns, so a conversion that also fixes a sizing error tends to outperform one that simply swaps fuel.
Gas line work and permit-required portions are performed through appropriately licensed partner professionals, coordinated as part of the overall project rather than left for you to arrange separately. We will tell you upfront which parts of your specific job fall into that category.
Yes. Multi-family and co-op conversions bring extra coordination — board approval, shared chimneys, access to a central mechanical room, and scheduling around tenants — but they are a normal part of what we do across the boroughs.
Before You Book
Worth Knowing
Need Oil-to-Gas Conversion?
Call now for same-day scheduling across New York City and Long Island.




